Inside the mesh

Why the teeth have the shapes they do, and why one bar is not enough.

A rack tooth has straight sides, sloping 1 in 4 from the vertical. The pinion teeth are curved: their sides are involutes, the curve traced by the end of a string unwound from a drum. An involute rolling on a straight flank keeps the push in one fixed direction however deep the teeth engage, so the mesh stays correct as wheels and rails wear. Riggenbach adopted this tooth form on the advice of the Zürich professor Carl Culmann, and every vertical rack since has kept its flank angle.

That fixed direction is the line of action. It is tilted, so every push has two parts: one along the track that drives the train, and one upward that tries to lift the pinion out of the rack.

The meshing lab

Snowdon's Abt rack, drawn to scale
Rack
Teeth in contact
Contact ratio, one bar
Drive along track
Lift on the pinion
The dots are where teeth touch. Each pair of teeth meets at the top of the rack tooth, slides down the line of action and parts at the pinion's tip. Snowdon rack: pitch 120 mm, teeth 18 mm above and 32 mm below the pitch line, flanks 1 in 4, 15-tooth pinion.

With one bar, a single pair of teeth carries the whole load for part of every pitch, and the load jumps from tooth to tooth as they hand over. Carl Roman Abt's answer was to lay two (or three) thin bars side by side, each staggered by a fraction of a tooth, with a pinion disc on each. There is then always a tooth in full engagement somewhere, the hand-overs are spread out and the drive runs smoothly. With three bars staggered by a third, and two pinions on the engine, a fresh tooth comes into mesh every 20 mm.

There was a catch. With the teeth staggered it is hard to make every pinion disc bear at once, so Abt's discs are mounted on springs that let each one turn a little against the others until all share the load.

A quarter of every driving push tries to lift the pinion out of the rack.

The lift is the danger. If the rack sags between its supports, or the track settles, or a train comes down too fast, the pinion can ride up and out of the teeth. Chapter 8 tells what happened on Snowdon's opening day.

Go deeper: the rules today

The Swiss rules for rack railways (AB-EBV 54.1.b) ask for a contact ratio of at least 1.15 for driving pinions, so that more than one tooth is always in mesh with a margin for wear, and at least 1.00 for brake pinions. The pinions on one vehicle must not be spaced a whole number of pitches apart, so their hand-overs never coincide. Snowdon's pinions are 1350 mm apart, 11¼ teeth, so they are a quarter of a tooth out of step.

One Snowdon bar on its own gives a contact ratio of 1.11 (computed from the 1896 drawings), a little under today's figure. With two bars the engine always has at least two teeth in mesh.

The rack flank's slope of 1 in 4 tilts the line of action at 14.04°, and tan 14.04° = 0.25: hence the quarter.

Sources: Engineering (1896), the Snowdon rack and engine; Swiss Federal Office of Transport, AB-EBV (2024), AB 33.1 and 54.1.b; V. von Röll (1923), "Zahnbahnen"; H. G. Wägli, "Carl Roman Abt" (2005); P. Berger, Ferrum 86 (2014).